Theoretical Weight Or Weighed Weight: How A Galvanized Square Tube Quote Is Really Priced

Nov 06, 2026

A buyer in Durban emailed me two quotes last month and asked which one was cheaper. Same size, 60x60x3 galvanized square tube, same EN 10219 grade, same destination port. One supplier quoted 690 dollars a tonne, we quoted 741. He assumed we were the expensive one. The difference was not really the price. It was the scale each tonne was measured on.

The first quote was priced on theoretical weight. Ours was priced on weighed weight. Until those two words are understood, the numbers cannot be compared at all, and I have watched this exact confusion cost buyers thousands of dollars over the years.

Bundles of galvanized square tube stacked in the yard ready for the weighbridge

What theoretical weight means

Theoretical weight is calculated, not measured. For a square tube you take the perimeter, multiply by wall thickness, then by 0.00785 to convert the steel volume into kilograms per metre. A 60x60x3 tube works out at about 5.37 kg per metre, and that number is what goes into a theoretical quote.

On paper it looks exact. It never is. The formula assumes the tube has perfectly sharp corners and perfectly even walls, and no tube I have ever unloaded looks like that. Real sections carry a rounded corner radius, which takes another three to five per cent off the true mass, and the wall itself is allowed to run below nominal. I once calipered a bundle that averaged 2.82 on a nominal 3.0 order. Legal, yes. What the buyer paid for, no.

Where the money leaks

Wall thickness is the big leak. Under EN 10219 and ASTM A500, a 3.0 millimetre wall may come in as low as 2.7, and mills rolling at the thin end are common because thin walls cost less to make. Run the same tube at 2.8 and it weighs about 5.03 kg per metre instead of 5.37. That is more than six per cent lighter. On a twenty-tonne order priced theoretically, you have paid for twenty tonnes and taken delivery of roughly eighteen and a half. Your real price per kilogram just rose six per cent, and the cheap-looking quote quietly stopped being cheap.

Then there is the zinc. A hot-dip coating adds weight, usually three to six per cent depending on coating mass. Some sellers invoice on the coated weight, some on the bare, and almost nobody states which one until the weighbridge ticket arrives and the two sides disagree about a number they never agreed on in the first place.

What weighed weight changes

Weighed weight is what the truck scale says. Every truck at our plant crosses the weighbridge loaded and again empty, the ticket goes into the shipment file next to the loading photos, and the invoice is made out against that figure. There is no formula to argue with afterwards. Tare, gross, net, one page, done. If the steel ran thin that day, we absorb the difference, not the customer.

This is why weighed quotes look higher. The seller is carrying the tolerance risk, the zinc mass question and the corner radius inside one number, so the per-tonne figure has to cover the worst case. A theoretical quote looks lower precisely because the buyer is carrying all of that, whether he knows it or not.

How to make two quotes comparable

Three questions settle it. Is the price theoretical or weighed? Which tolerance class does the wall run to, and does the mill roll mid-range or minimum? Does the invoiced weight include the coating? Any supplier who cannot answer those three in writing is not really quoting you. He is guessing, and the guess only ever goes one way.

Convert everything to a landed cost per tonne of steel you will actually receive. If the theoretical quote assumes 5.37 kg per metre and the real tube will weigh 5.03, add six per cent to that price before you put it next to a weighed one. Do the sum and the quote that looked 51 dollars expensive in Durban came out cheaper per kilogram of delivered steel.

He ordered from us anyway, and not only because of the arithmetic. He told me later it was the first time a supplier had sent weighbridge tickets along with the loading photos without being chased for them. That habit costs us nothing and it settles more arguments than any clause in a contract.